PagerDuty is a well-known leader in the on-call management and alerting space, but it's not the only solution available. While popular, many engineering and Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) teams find themselves searching for PagerDuty alternatives. These searches are often driven by factors like complex pricing structures, perceived feature gaps, or the need for a more comprehensive incident management platform that goes beyond simple alerting. For many organizations, concerns about PagerDuty's pricing and the complexity of its plans are significant motivators for exploring other options [3].

This article compares the top incident management tools to help you find the best fit for your team's needs. We'll examine Rootly, Opsgenie, and Splunk On-Call, providing a clear comparison of their capabilities as SRE tools for incident tracking and response.

Why Look for a PagerDuty Alternative?

PagerDuty has strong brand recognition in the incident alerting market, making it a default choice for many [1]. However, as teams mature their DevOps incident management practices, they often encounter limitations that prompt a search for alternatives. The primary reasons include:

• Cost: PagerDuty's pricing can escalate quickly as teams grow, leading them to seek more cost-effective solutions that don't compromise on functionality.
• Desire for a Unified Platform: Many teams want a single, integrated platform that manages the entire incident lifecycle—from the initial alert through investigation, resolution, and the final retrospective—rather than just handling on-call schedules and notifications.
• Automation and Workflow Needs: There is a growing demand for advanced automation capabilities to reduce the manual toil associated with incident response. This includes automating tasks like creating communication channels, pulling in the right responders, and provisioning resources.
• Integration with Existing Stacks: Finding a tool that integrates more deeply and seamlessly with a team's existing technology stack, such as the Atlassian suite or specific observability platforms, is a critical factor for operational efficiency.

The Top PagerDuty Alternatives: A Detailed Comparison

When you compare oncall platforms, it's important to look beyond alerting to the full scope of incident management. Here’s a detailed look at some of the best oncall software for teams.

1. Rootly

Overview:
Rootly is a comprehensive, end-to-end incident management software built to serve as the central command center for your entire response process. It moves beyond basic on-call alerting to focus on robust automation and deep collaboration within the tools your team already uses, like Slack and Microsoft Teams. Rootly can function as a complete replacement for PagerDuty with its own native on-call scheduling and alerting, or it can be a powerful addition, integrating with PagerDuty to supercharge its capabilities with advanced incident workflows.

Key Features:

• Powerful, no-code workflow engine to automate tasks like creating Slack channels, inviting responders, escalating to the right teams, and updating status pages.
• Native Slack and Microsoft Teams integration, allowing teams to manage the entire incident lifecycle without leaving their primary communication hub.
• Automated generation of post-mortems and retrospectives with rich timelines, key metrics, and actionable insights.
• Built-in on-call scheduling, escalations, and alerting (Rootly On-Call).
• Integrated action item tracking with connections to project management tools like Jira and Asana.

Best For:

• Teams seeking a modern, all-in-one incident management solution to automate processes, centralize response efforts, and foster a culture of continuous learning.
• Organizations that are heavy users of Slack or MS Teams and want to streamline their incident response directly within those platforms.

2. Opsgenie (by Atlassian)

Overview:
Opsgenie is a formidable PagerDuty competitor and a strong choice for those already embedded in the Atlassian ecosystem. Its primary strengths lie in flexible on-call scheduling and sophisticated alerting rules. For teams that rely heavily on other Atlassian products, Opsgenie offers a seamless integration experience that can streamline workflows between alerting and development tracking [6].

Key Features:

• Deep integration with Jira Service Management and Confluence for cohesive incident and issue tracking.
• Advanced reporting and analytics on alerts, on-call schedules, and team performance.
• Robust on-call scheduling with multiple schedule types and flexible escalation policies.
• Alert enrichment and filtering capabilities to reduce noise and add context.

Best For:

• Teams heavily invested in the Atlassian suite (Jira, Confluence, Bitbucket) who want to keep their alerting and on-call management within the same product family.

Note on Integration:
While Opsgenie is a powerful standalone alerting tool, it can also be integrated with platforms like Rootly. This combination allows teams to leverage Opsgenie's alerting capabilities while benefiting from Rootly's advanced incident management automation and collaboration features.

3. Splunk On-Call (formerly VictorOps)

Overview:
Splunk On-Call, previously known as VictorOps, is an incident response and alert management software designed for modern DevOps and SRE teams. Its main advantage is for organizations that have already standardized on the Splunk observability platform for logging, monitoring, and security.

Key Features:

• Intelligent alert routing and noise reduction to combat alert fatigue.
• Context-rich incident timelines that bring together monitoring data, alerts, and team collaboration in one view.
• The "Transmogrifier" feature allows for powerful customization and enrichment of incoming alerts before they are sent.
• Automated escalations and flexible on-call scheduling.

Best For:

• Organizations that use Splunk as their primary observability and security information and event management (SIEM) platform.

Feature Comparison Table: PagerDuty vs. The Alternatives

Feature

PagerDuty

Rootly

Opsgenie

Splunk On-Call

Core Function

On-Call & Alerting

End-to-End Incident Management

On-Call & Alerting

On-Call & Alerting

On-Call & Scheduling

Yes

Yes (Rootly On-Call)

Yes

Yes

Incident Automation

Limited (Add-on)

Yes (Core Feature)

Limited

Limited

Retrospectives

Basic

Yes (Automated, Data-Rich)

Basic

Basic

Slack-Native Experience

Limited (App)

Yes (Fully Native)

Limited (App)

Limited (App)

Best for...

Large enterprises needing robust alerting

Teams wanting to automate the entire incident lifecycle

Teams in the Atlassian ecosystem

Teams using the Splunk observability platform

Pricing Model

Per User, Tiered

Per User, Tiered

Per User, Tiered

Per User, Tiered

What’s Included in the Modern SRE Tooling Stack?

The modern approach to reliability management extends far beyond simple on-call alerting. A comprehensive SRE tooling stack is a layered ecosystem designed to ensure system resilience and rapid recovery. The essential components are:

• Observability & Monitoring: Tools that collect telemetry data—metrics, logs, and traces—to provide deep visibility into system health (e.g., Datadog, Prometheus, New Relic).
• Alerting & On-Call: Systems responsible for notifying the right people at the right time when an issue is detected (e.g., PagerDuty, Opsgenie, Rootly On-Call).
• Incident Management Platform: A central hub to coordinate the response, automate repetitive tasks, manage communication, and serve as the system of record for all incidents. This is where a tool like Rootly excels.
• Collaboration: The communication tools where teams work and collaborate during an incident (e.g., Slack, Microsoft Teams).
• Post-Incident Learning: Platforms for generating data-driven retrospectives (post-mortems) and tracking action items to drive systemic improvements and prevent future failures.

A unified platform like Rootly is designed to consolidate the incident management, collaboration, and post-incident learning layers, creating a single, cohesive solution that integrates seamlessly with your observability and alerting tools.

How to Choose the Right On-Call Software for Your Team

When evaluating PagerDuty alternatives, it's crucial to select a tool that aligns with your team's specific needs and operational maturity. Here are some steps to guide your decision:

1. Assess Your Pain Points: Identify your biggest challenges. Are you struggling with alert fatigue, slow response times due to manual processes, or inconsistent post-incident follow-up? Your pain points will dictate the features you should prioritize.
2. Evaluate Integrations: A tool's value is magnified by how well it connects with your existing stack. Check for deep integrations with your monitoring, ticketing, and communication tools. The number and quality of integrations are critical for building a seamless workflow [7].
3. Consider Your Workflow: Choose a tool that fits naturally into how your team already works. A solution with a strong, native experience in a collaboration hub like Slack can dramatically reduce context switching and improve efficiency.
4. Prioritize Automation: Look for a solution that automates repetitive, low-value tasks. This frees up your responders to focus their cognitive energy on diagnosing and resolving the problem, which is the most critical part of incident response.
5. Compare Total Cost of Ownership (TCO): Don't just look at the subscription price. Consider the time saved through automation, the reduction in mean time to resolution (MTTR), and the long-term value of improved reliability. Some platforms offer highly competitive pricing models designed for scaling teams [4].

Conclusion: Why Rootly is the Best PagerDuty Alternative

While PagerDuty, Opsgenie, and Splunk On-Call are all strong tools for on-call management and alerting, they don't provide the same comprehensive, end-to-end incident management experience as Rootly. For teams looking to move beyond basic alerting and truly mature their incident management process, Rootly stands out as the superior alternative.

Rootly is built for teams that prioritize automation, collaboration, and continuous learning. It provides a single platform to manage the entire incident lifecycle, reducing manual toil and enabling faster, more consistent resolutions. Whether you're looking to replace PagerDuty entirely or supercharge it by adding a robust incident management layer, Rootly provides a flexible and powerful solution.

Ready to see how Rootly can transform your incident management? Book a personalized demo or start your free trial today.

‍

‍